'True remorse depends, to my mind, on a man's accurate knowledge of his own motives.'
1881 first English edition in three volumes
Collins's novel was published in 1881 and elaborates on a theme first used in 'The
Yellow Mask' (1855). In both, a
high ranking Catholic priest schemes to recover property he considers to
belong rightfully to the church. Mr
Murthwaite, the renowned traveller from The
Moonstone (1868), makes a very brief appearance as does Dr Wybrow,
first seen in The Haunted Hotel (1879).
Collins wrote to William Winter in September 1881 that it was thought
in 'Roman Catholic countries as well as Protestant England, to be the best
thing I have written for some time. And
it is especially memorable to me as having produced a freely offered gift of
forty pounds from one of the pirates on the American side!!!'
The pirate was probably George Munro of the Seaside Library.
1885 Chatto & Windus yellowback
Lewis Romayne, accompanied by his old friend Major Hynd, is in Boulogne
to see his dying aunt. He is
involved in a quarrel over a card game, challenged to a duel and accidentally
kills his opponent. The plaintive
screams of the dead Frenchman's younger brother afterwards haunt Romayne for
Distracted with remorse, Romayne returns first to London and then to his
Yorkshire home, Vange Abbey, confiscated at the dissolution of the monasteries
and given to one of his ancestors by Henry VIII.
Even at Vange he still hears the French boy's voice and escapes to
London to visit another old friend, Lord Loring, head of a prominent Catholic
family. Staying with Lady Loring
is Stella Eyrecourt who falls in love with Romayne.
Father Benwell, acting as the Lorings' spiritual advisor, is determined
to convert Romayne and restore Vange to the church with the help of the young
priest, Arthur Penrose.
Romayne, vulnerable and still troubled by the duel, sends Major Hynd to
enquire about the Frenchman's family, now living in London, hoping he can at
least assist them financially. He
also confides in Penrose who, despite his ulterior motives, forms a genuine
friendship with Romayne and accepts that marriage to Stella, though she is a
Protestant, is best for his long-term happiness.
Benwell plans to undermine the marriage and introduces Romayne to the
wealthy Bernard Winterfield whom he knows has a past connection with Stella.
When Stella's worldly mother is taken ill Benwell meets her physician,
Dr Wybrow, who innocently mentions Stella's earlier romance with Winterfield.
Wybrow also talks of a deranged French boy (in fact the duellist's
brother) found with papers stolen from Winterfield.
Benwell agrees to return the documents but first breaks the seal to
discover they contain a confession from Winterfield's separated wife Emma, now
dead, a circus performer and a drunkard. Jealous
of his love for Stella, Emma arranged for a false announcement of her death to
be put in the papers, and then greeted him outside the church after the
bigamous marriage ceremony. Stella
was immediately removed by her relatives and the marriage hushed up.
Penrose is called to Rome and then sent to a mission in America.
Benwell resolves to manage Romayne's conversion himself and succeeds
where Penrose failed. Romayne, not
knowing that Stella is pregnant, goes to a Retreat where Benwell cleverly
manoeuvres him into leaving Vange Abbey to the church in his will.
Benwell also tells Romayne that in the eyes of the church he is still a
single man. Winterfield's registry
office wedding to his first wife, though legal, is not recognised by the
Catholic authorities. His second
marriage to Stella, although annulled by the courts, is irrevocably recognised
by the church. Romayne's own
marriage to Stella is therefore void and he is free to fulfil his vocation to
become a priest.
Stella leaves England to live with her mother in Paris.
Winterfield, still in love with Stella, is anxious to avoid any further
scandal. He therefore takes a long
sailing trip to the East, returning via Rome where he learns that Romayne has
made rapid advancement in the church because of his diplomatic skills.
Reading a report in The Times by Mr Murthwaite that Penrose is
held captive by American Indians, Winterfield embarks on a successful rescue.
Romayne has been promoted to an ecclesiastical post in Paris but, knowing
he is dying, consents for the first time to see Stella and his son.
Benwell brings Romayne's family lawyer to his death bed to confirm the
validity of the will and ensure the church can inherit Vange.
In his last moments, Romayne finally acknowledges his love for his wife
and child and the will is destroyed. The
inheritance passes to his family and not to the church.
Stella fulfils Romayne's final wish and marries Winterfield.
1881 US edition by Belford, Clarke of Chicago
The Sheffield and Rotherham Independent Supplement,
2 October 1880--26 March 1881 ('Specially written for The Independent'), and
several other provincial newspapers; The Canadian Monthly, November
3 Volumes, Chatto & Windus, London 1881.
Black cloth, covers blocked in white, spines lettered in gilt.
Blue and white floral end-papers. Half-title
in each volume. Published in April
viii (numbered vi) + 320 pp
viii (numbered vi) + 296 pp
viii (numbered vi) + 272 pp. Publishers'
advertisements occupy pp (267-272). 32
pp publishers' catalogue dated March 1881 bound in
Second edition, 3 volumes, 1881.
1 volume Chatto & Windus editions 1884-1901.
Sutton, Stroud 1994.
1st US edition
Seaside Library, New York 1881.
Russian, St Petersburg 1881, 1882; German, Berlin 1882.
All material in these pages is © copyright Andrew Gasson 1998-2010